1. Entertainment

Discuss in my forum

Readers Respond: Major or Indie?

Responses: 7

By , About.com Guide

If you had to choose between a major and an independent label, what would you pick? Pick your poison

Major or Indie

Well I'd have to choose Major because of FAME? I don't really know right now but I'm a rap/hip-hop writer in progress but yeah I'd sink into debt to get FAME anytime.
—Guest LiL'Lincoln

Rhymesayers (Warner) Stones Throw (EMI)

Could the long-term success of indie labels like Stones and Rhymesayers possibly have anything to do with the fact that they're distributed by majors, and can often use promotional, marketing, and synch services that those majors operate on a scale larger than any indie could ever afford?
—Guest fonkindontknowhow

INDIE

Indie. Labels like QN4, Stone's Throw, Rawkus (before) and Rhymesayers etc ARE hip hop
—Guest Jeff

Major or Indie

I would actually pick neither, because if the music is good, it doesn't matter where it came from. It can come from someone's basement for all the I care. The quality of the music is all that matters, not the label that it came from.
—Guest Mark

Depends

I prefer personally indie, as the artist has more freedom and can make the music they want. However, as an artist looking to make money, it is more likely to come with a major label push. To me though, I am more likely to purchase an indie album, as hip hop is still alive in the indie community
—Guest Harry

Reno Smiff...INDIEISM (The NEW religion)

SUPERB piece, Mr. Adaso! Check ur email. My response was WAY too lengthy! LOL!
—Guest Reno Smiff

Mr. Adaso is seriously on-point!

Mr. Adaso, you are the man. I would have to say, go Indie. Retain the rights to your work. Take care of yourself. The desire for fame is making us all crazy. Stay true to your craft. Like my man, Q-Tip, said, "record companies are shady..so kids watch your back, `cause I think they smoke crack, I don't doubt it look at how they act." Need further proof: Listen to EMPD's classic track, "Crossover" or even BDP's "Outta Here". This is real education about the industry. Props to KRS-One for telling us the truth all these years.
—Guest Sir Reginald

Pick your poison

Major or Indie?

Receive a one-time notification when your response is published.

©2012 About.com. All rights reserved.

A part of The New York Times Company.